PDF Download Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock
Based upon some encounters of many people, it remains in truth that reading this Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock can help them to make far better choice and provide even more experience. If you wish to be among them, let's acquisition this publication Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock by downloading guide on link download in this website. You could get the soft documents of this publication Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock to download and install as well as put aside in your offered digital gadgets. Exactly what are you waiting for? Let get this book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock on the internet and review them in whenever and also any type of location you will certainly check out. It will certainly not encumber you to bring heavy book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock within your bag.
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock
PDF Download Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock
Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock In fact, publication is actually a home window to the globe. Also many individuals could not like reviewing books; the books will certainly constantly provide the exact info regarding reality, fiction, experience, adventure, politic, religion, and also more. We are below an internet site that offers compilations of books more than the book shop. Why? We offer you great deals of varieties of link to obtain the book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock On is as you need this Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock You can locate this book effortlessly right here.
The advantages to take for reviewing guides Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock are pertaining to improve your life quality. The life quality will certainly not simply regarding the amount of knowledge you will gain. Even you review the enjoyable or enjoyable books, it will certainly assist you to have enhancing life top quality. Feeling fun will lead you to do something perfectly. In addition, guide Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock will give you the lesson to take as an excellent factor to do something. You could not be worthless when reading this e-book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock
Don't bother if you do not have sufficient time to head to guide shop and also look for the preferred e-book to review. Nowadays, the on-line publication Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock is involving offer convenience of reviewing behavior. You might not should go outdoors to browse guide Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock Searching as well as downloading guide entitle Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock in this write-up will provide you better remedy. Yeah, on-line book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock is a sort of digital book that you can get in the web link download offered.
Why should be this on the internet book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock You may not need to go somewhere to read the e-books. You can review this e-book Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock whenever and every where you desire. Even it remains in our extra time or feeling tired of the tasks in the office, this corrects for you. Obtain this Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock today as well as be the quickest person who finishes reading this publication Julian The Apostate, By G. W. Bowersock
This portrayal of one of antiquity's most enigmatic figures offers a vivid and compact assessment of the Apostate's life and reign. Proceeding directly from an evaluation of the ancient sources--the testimony of friends and enemies of Julian as well as the writings of the emperor himself--the author traces Julian's youth, his years as the commander of the Roman forces in Gaul, and his emergence as sole ruler in the course of a dramatic march to Constantinople. In Bowersock's analysis of Julian's religious revolution, the emperor's ardent espousal of a lost cause is seen to have made intolerable demands upon pagans, Jews, and Christians alike.
- Sales Rank: #909330 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Harvard University Press
- Published on: 1997-03-25
- Released on: 1997-02-15
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 8.50" h x .39" w x 5.63" l, .51 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 152 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
Review
Bowersock has written the best narrative history of Julian's career...His success is due not only to the vivid style but to the command of the very wide variety of sources that enables him to derive new insights from unexpected facts. (W. H. C. Frend New York Review of Books)
The most reliable and lucid account available of Julian's haunting obsession...An extraordinarily good book about an extraordinary man. (George Steiner London Times)
Packed with skillfully deployed information and remarkable insights...The picture is drawn with an incisive vigor which is completely convincing, and with unusual elegance of style. (J. N. D. Kelly The Observer)
From the Back Cover
This portrayal of one of antiquity's most enigmatic figures offers a vivid and compact assessment of the Apostate's life and reign. Proceeding directly from an evaluation of the ancient sources - the testimony of friends and enemies of Julian as well as the writings of the emperor himself - the author traces Julian's youth, his years as the commander of the Roman forces in Gaul, and his emergence as sole ruler in the course of a dramatic march to Constantinople. In Bowersock's analysis of Julian's religious revolution, the emperor's ardent espousal of a lost cause is seen to have made intolerable demands upon pagans, Jews, and Christians alike.
About the Author
G. W. Bowersock is Professor Emeritus of Ancient History at the Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton.
Most helpful customer reviews
82 of 90 people found the following review helpful.
Interesting, but Biased Account of a Fascinating Figure.
By Stefan Cover
There are certain historical figures that are nearly impossible to get to know in anything approaching an objective sense. Something about them compels us to a judgement. Julian the Apostate is one of those rare figures who forces us to react emotionally - no matter how objective we think we are. And our reaction often says more about who WE are, than about the object of our judgement.
Flavius Julianus was the last pagan Emperor of Rome. He briefly attempted to reverse the ongoing Christianization of the Roman Empire begun by his detested uncle, the Emperor Constantine. He failed miserably and died young, but his attempt to reverse the cultural tides of his day will always fascinate any who encounter Julian and his century.
Glen Bowersock's book is a classic example of 20th Century historical revisionism. The historical consensus concerning Julian since the time of Gibbon and Voltaire has been cautiously admiring on the whole. Bowersock seeks to reverse that consensus by reinterpeting the abundant historical evidence. In doing so his dislike of Julian is displayed on nearly every page. I can't go into detail here, but there are numerous instances in which the author achieves a "new" interpretation by placing the very worst construction on the evidence. In nearly every case he favors whatever presents Julian in the least favorable light. Nowhere is this more evident than in Bowersock's account of Julian's "usurpation" of the title of Augustus in 361. He strains every nerve to prove the mutiny of the soldiers was engineered by Julian and his friends and that they lied about it later, all against formidable evidence to the contrary.
That being said, this is an interesting book. The author does a good job introducing the historical context, and his scholarly account of the facts of Julian's life is lively. Read the darn thing, but do yourself a favor and read the best account ever written of Julian's reign, that contained in the Res Gestae of Ammianus Marcellinus. It is available in translation as a Penguin paperback. Ammianus served in Julian's army and was a balanced witness of the Apostate's good and bad qualities. Julian was a complex man. He was a soldier, emperor, scholar, orator, philosopher, even a political prisoner for some years, and a deeply religious pagan. He was also credulous, didactic, a fanatic, an egomaniac, and even a public nuisance upon occasion. In the end however, our very best witness, Ammianus, admired Julian greatly. I must confess, so do I.
30 of 33 people found the following review helpful.
Scholarly, Researched, Biased
By Arch Stanton
I wanted to like this book. I really did. I'm not a massive fan of Julian like some of the other reviewers here are. I appreciate the man for what he was but I never idolized him as some sort of pagan crusader. Reading some of these reviews before I started the book I wasn't worried since so many of them seem to be slightly batty. Unfortunately, they're also right. I had to write an essay on Julian so I read a lot on him. There are several other biographies out there (The Last Pagan and The Emperor Julian are quite good) and they capture the man's essence better than Bowersock. Many of the books that I had to read, scholarly works included, insult this book pretty blatantly. Rowland Smith in his book 'Julian's Gods' spends several pages rebuking Bowersock's vision of Julian as a "pathological figure." He is polite enough not to mention him obviously by name, but a quick glance at the footnotes reveals that every time he criticizes this interpretation he is referencing Bowersock. The way in which Bowersock managed to compact all of Julian's life into 119 pages is by dismissing all of Julian's religious views as unimportant (You learn nothing except that he was pagan and fancied himself a philosopher), and skimming over anything that seems to his credit. Julian was, for example, unquestionably the most approachable emperor of the Fourth Century, largely because he based his style of rule on Rome's previous philosopher-king Marcus Aurelius. All that Bowersock says about this is something snide about how he seemed to see himself in everyone he admired, no matter how dissimilar.
I truly don't know what problem this guy has with Julian. Every time he has more than one source of information he goes with the most insulting or critical one. For example: on page 107 he describes how two martyrs (Bonosus and Maximilianus) were beheaded for not removing the Christian symbol from their standards whereas it is just as likely that they were actually executed for criticizing the Emperor just before battle. He took the heavily biased stories from the Christians and takes them at face value while dismissing the pagan ones. In a similar vein he takes his description for Julian's behavior from possibly his greatest enemy Gregory of Nazianzus and says that it is essentially true.
Some examples of bias from his own words include: "when Julian died, all Christians and many pagans received the news with relief." That's right off of page 1 and the point is very debatable. Certainly he doesn't have the evidence to prove that. Julian's writings are described as being "petulant and self-righteous" and filled with his "unsettling laughter." (13) "Like them [Lenin and Mao-Tse-Tung who he's comparing him to], Julian was neither gregarious nor, in the social sense of the term, even civilized." (20)
Essentially, the way that Julian is described is as a dull, humorless, cruel, ascetic, self-righteous, unprincipled, puritanical, savage, bigot. I am using only words that Bowersock himself applies to Julian throughout the course of the book. This is not the language of an unbiased historian. To anyone who doubts that these traits do not describe, or at least dominate, Julian need only read his own writings. He has written three books worth of various works from orations to letters to satires. How Bowersock can describe the author of the Caesars as a dull and humorless person is beyond me. Sure it's not sidesplittingly hilarious, but the tone is very lighthearted throughout and you can feel the tongue kept very much in cheek. Bowersock however, takes it as a serious expression of Julian's beliefs even though Julian himself describes it as a comic work. The same goes for the Beard-Hater. Although that one is rather more bitter it can hardly be described as a "hectoring, injured, [and] repetitive" work filled with "Julian's unsettling laughter."
Until I read these works for myself I had no reason to doubt that his interpretation was true. Now I can't even see hints of his belief. Please don't take my word for this. Read those books yourself. They reveal a lot about the man's character and they are sometimes very entertaining. They are available in Loeb editions (Volume I, Volume II, Volume III) which are kind of expensive, but they are probably available for free online as well. So do yourself a favor and skip this book. Read one of the other excellent biographies. 'The Last Pagan' is probably the most readable of the two. Or read the works of the contemporary historian Ammianus Marcellinus (Volume I, Volume II, Volume III) or Julian's friend Libanius (Orations, Volume I, Orations, Volume II). These books will provide you with a much more accurate glimpse of the man who has come down through history as Julian the Apostate.
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful.
Author all but ignores Julian's anti-Christian polemics.
By A Customer
I found the book thoroughgoing in biographic details on Julian's life. But particularly disappointing is the author's neglect of Julian's anti-Christian arguments, which make fascinating reading. Oddly, Bowersock ignores, in his Bibliography, the 3-volume set of Julian's writings published some years ago by Loeb Classics. This omission is especially galling since B. maintains many of J.'s writings are unavailable, but some he so characterizes ARE available in the Loeb volumes! Of particular interest was J.'s diatribe against the "Galilean," Jesus--which is found in Loeb, but all but ignored in Bowersock's book. This is perplexing to say the least.
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock PDF
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock EPub
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock Doc
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock iBooks
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock rtf
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock Mobipocket
Julian the Apostate, by G. W. Bowersock Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar